That's actually what I was thinking. She'd either forget everything from that night (including seeing Aria with Mr. Fitz) and the series would just give her like tiny flashbacks to drive you crazy. OR she'd be like in a coma or something so she couldn't talk anyway.

Yeah, I doubt it too. I agree, it's waaay too cliche.
Speaking of Hanna, what do you think is going to happen to her? I don't think she'll die because I doubt they'd kill off a main character. I think she'll probably lose some of her memory and won't remember anything that happened that night.

A twin? I doubt it. I mean, if anything it's too cliché, you know?
I don't think Noel really can prove anything. Apart from Aria and Ezra, the only others who know (or knew) are Hanna and A. And A managed to shut Hanna up

You know I've always wondered about that. They never mentioned that again and I wanted to know so badly who it was! Maybe she was just seeing things? Someone's lame theory was that "Allison has a twin sister!", but how would the girls not know about her?
I'm wondering if Noel will tell on Mr. Fitz and Aria. Since he walked in on them talking about "letting go of each other" or something like that.

That is actually pretty good. And Melissa was only supposed to be in New York, I know from my poor geography that New York is just above Pennsylvania where Rosewood is supposed to be.
Something that always confused me but was never revisited was the night Spencer got her first message from A "Poor Spencer, always wants Melissa's boyfriends. But remember, if you kiss, I tell. -A" Spencer looked up and saw a blonde girl through the window of the next house. But there's never been any mention (I don't think) of her neighbours or anything so there's no clue about who that was.

Ooh, yes, that's really good reasoning. I would have never thought of that. Although, I think it might be Melissa (Spencer's sister). Allison was also with Ian, Melissa's boyfriend. That would have given Melissa a good motive to want to get rid of her. And, it would have been easy for her to get in Spencer's closet and write on the mirror, because she's her sister and it would have been easy for her to get in the house. Dunno, just one of my theories. xD

Because she was the one who 'went looking' for Alison the night she disappeared. The thing with the words on the mirror were in her room and would have been easy for her to set up if she had someone to help her do the camera inside the closet thing. And she had a good motive to get rid of Alison after she saw Spencer kissing her sister's boyfriend.

Sure, that sounds like a good plan.
And I know I don't want to wait that long! I want to know what happened to Hannah soooo badly!!
And really? Lol. xD Why did you think she was A?

Omg YES Hanna and Lucas would be adorable!
Hm... How about you kidnap Ezra and I get Aria?
2011?!?!?!?!?!
Yeah okay I'm going with plan B and saving for the books.
Can you believe I honestly thought A was Spencer for a while?

LMAO. I don't want Ezra to die! I love him.
I really want Hanna and Lucas (the dorky kid) to get together. How cute would that be? xD
And I can't believe we have to wait until 2011 until the next episodes. Maybe I'll just read all of the books. I read the first one and it was good, and slightly different. Plus I heard the A in the show is going to be different than A in the books!