That does make sense, maybe she was a bitch because she's so self conscious about herself. Makes sense.
I actually don't know, to be honest. You're right, if she knew, I suppose she would rat them out. Or maybe she's A or working with A and she knows it was them and wants to torture them with the texts and threats.
I think that pretty much any accent except an American one is sexy. American accents are just so boring and mundane. I probably think that because I live here.
Hmmm... maybe. I really can't wait until all of our questions finally get answered.
Bahaha. It might just be a coincidence. I doubt Maya or Dr. Sullivan is A.

Even then, I mean Emily thought her and Ali were really, really close and Ali was straight and didn't take well to Emily kissing her shoulder that one time. It seemed like Ali could make people believe she was really close to them but it was just an act. I can't see her being truly close to anyone. I think she was insecure and the confidence was all an act. She was scared to get close to anyone.
Are we sure Jenna knows it was them. I know Ali kept Toby quiet, but what stopped Jenna from ratting them out if she knew?
What is it with Americans and finding "British" accents sexy? Hardly anyone actually talks like that. :|
I think there's something going on with Mike and Jason.
I never noticed the boots thing.

To be honest, I really can't either, unless Ali was in love with Ian and thought it was a deep intimate relationship or something of that sort. I really want to know what kind of secrets Ali had herself. The girls confided in her but did she really confide in them?
Jenna is very freaky and I think you're right, there's more to her. I would be really pissed off if some girl did something that resulted in me becoming blind, but not angry enough to kill her.
I really can't wait to see what happens with Dr. Sullivan. A wouldn't let her get away with knowing who he/she is, so there's gotta be more to it.
I really hope that's true. I don't want her getting back with Wren. (Well, they weren't really together, but you know what I mean. ) He's cute and his accent is sexy, but her and Toby are a better fit. And Toby is crazy about her. I don't think Wren would shout "I love you!" and try to fight away policemen to get to her.
It would make sense if Jenna did. It really doesn't make sense for Mike to be getting A texts, but I really think his behavior lately + his breaking in to houses has to tie into the whole plot line somehow. Or maybe it doesn't and it's just to raise suspicion. Maybe he's just severely depressed and struggling with his own problems.
Well, Hannah made a comment on Maya's boots and then the camera showed them and they looked a lot like the ones that A purchased online at the end of an episode about a month back or so.

That's true, but I can't see Ali confiding in anyone. It's like they said at the beginning, she knew all of their secrets, but really, how much did they know about her?
Hmmm. The thing about Jenna though, I think that there's more to her than she lets on. There's definitely something we're either missing, or she hasn't showed yet. It just doesn't seem to fit right.
Dr. Sullivan, I don't know. There is just no way A would let her waltz out of there and be able to freely tell the girls everything. There just HAS to be a catch somewhere. There must be.
I think the thing with Wren was just because she was so in shock over everything and confused and mixed up and he was there for her, she appreciated that. I doubt she actually loves him as much as she does Toby.
I'm sure Jenna got a message or something from A at one point, I might be wrong. But there was definitely someone else. I guess he could be, but I don't see why. I mean, the whole point of it being "A" is that it's the first letter of Alison's name, so it's centred around everyone Alison was close to or connected with in some way. So unless she secretly dated Mike or something, I can't see why A would be texting him.
I never noticed the boots. Ah well.
LUCAS!!

Alison definitely wasn't a normal teenager. But she probably did have a diary or something with her feelings and secrets kept in it. It does seem possible. Maybe Ali revealed secrets to Ian, not knowing that he was possibly setting her up for murder.
I think that Jenna has been working with Garrett the whole time. They killed Ali and are doing everything they can to pin it on other people. For instance, when someone was trying to frame Toby and then Spencer. Maybe Garrett and Jenna are together, maybe they're just sleeping together. I'm not sure. I still don't know what that whole motel thing was about, a while back. Why was Jenna staying in a motel? Did they reveal that or not? I can't remember There are so many details from past episodes.
I'm thinking it was probably a dream. Ali was a huge bitch but I absolutely love when she shows up in episodes.
I can't even remember that kid's name. But I always wondered if he might be A. He destroyed Alison's memorial. But it was a dead giveaway when he forgot to wipe the mud off of his shoes. A is too smart for that. Maybe Dr. Sullivan is being forced to work with A now. I hope not, though, because the girls really trusted her.
I know, poor Toby. I was so sad for him because the breakup was so out of the blue. Just a few hours before they were talking about what their kid was going to look like and then she's breaking up with him and kissing Wren. I'm going to miss Spoby. I hope this breakup doesn't last for long.
Has it ever occurred to you that the girls might not be the only ones getting A texts? I thought about that before and wondered if it's true. Mike has been really depressed and angry lately, so I'm wondering if he's being tortured by A as well. Maybe Mike is A. He seems so full of angst at times. Maybe he has multiple personalities or something of the sort and one of them is A. Something must be eating at him and causing him to be so distraught lately. Maybe he's secretly gay and is with Noel Kahn or someone!
Did you notice that Maya was wearing the boots that A ordered? Dr. Sullivan was as well. Either they're A, the boots were anonymously sent by A, or it's just a freaky coincidence. I was watching an episode from a few weeks back and Dr. Sullivan was wearing them. And then watching the finale the second time, I realized Maya was.
Oh, you're right, I forgot. Hannah's dad looked so disappointed. He had just forgiven Hannah and talked to her about how happy Isabelle makes him, and then she kind of threw that all back in his face. (For reasons that he doesn't know, of course.)
I heard that it's going to be a really scary episode. If that's true, then these girls must be pretty damn used to going through horrific stuff. I'm interested too about Alison. I want to see more on what they were like and how they acted with Ali.
Bahaha, I know. We do take this pretty seriously. xD It's fun speculating!

OH, I remember now! His name is Lucas.

I think she probably did and had it hidden somewhere since she was so good at that stuff. What kind of teenage girl doesn't keep a diary (or blog) somewhere? Then again, Ali wasn't a normal teenager, was she?
I'm completely lost with Jenna and Garrett, they are definitely up to something and I can't help wondering if one of them is only dating (or whatever the hell they're doing) the other just because they need the information, if that makes sense.
Maybe Alison didn't really tell Emily that and it was just a dream? She was unconscious and it could have been A who dragged her out of the barn because they didn't want to kill her, just mess with her head and scare her. The two people she'd be thinking about most would be Dr. Sullivan, A, and Ali, she was really close to Ali so it makes sense she'd dream about her, you know?
It was the kissing rock.
Personally, ....Crap what's his name.. The guy who was on the yearbook that had the huge crush on Hanna, the geeky guy. His eyes always stuck out at me. But he was so nice. I don't think Dr. Sullivan will ever be free. A wouldn't risk anyone being able to tell the girls who they are. There must be a catch. Either Dr. Sullivan will be kidnapped, killed, or is still being threatened with something so she won't tell the girls anything.
Me too! I know it was for his own good but I wanted to cry, he was so upset about losing her. Between that and Ella thinking that Ezra was dating Spencer, people must think she's throwing herself out there a lot.
I know, right? But I think Kate probably will be glad if she finds out that Hanna's dad cheated on her mum with his ex wife. I mean, anyone would hate someone for that, right? I'm more worried about what's going to happen between Hanna and her dad. Did you see the look on his face?
I heard about it but I didn't know it was a kind of "2 years earlier" thing. It sounds good, though because I'm so fascinated with Alison and want to learn more about her and what she was like.
What makes me laugh is how seriously we take this. It's like, after the end of an episode we're just like "OH MY GOD DID YOU SEE THAT?! *very long string of theories about every little thing that just happened*"

I know!! Totally crazy
Maybe she did keep a diary? I don't know. A and the killers are most likely in it together. I mean, wasn't it Jenna and Garrett who put the shovel by the barn?
I know xD If she were to take pictures of anyone, it would be Emily, since she said Emily was her favourite. But maybe Ali is just one big tease who wants to mess with Emily's head!
Yep, it would mean that he's an accomplice, and really, that the murder wouldn't have happened that night if it hadn't been for Ian taking Ali to the Kissing Rock. (Is it the kissing rock? Or is it tree? Or stone? bahaha, I don't know.)
What sticks out to me was the end, in the cafe, with A and Dr. Sullivan. And the waitress came up and called A "pretty eyes." I'm trying to think of who we know who has pretty eyes! And I'm wondering what Dr. Sullivan will do now that she's free. She knows who A is, after all. And what did she mean by "I did everything you told me to do"? I hope she isn't betraying the girls, they really trusted her and did a hell of a lot of damage to save her. I felt so bad about Spencer breaking up with Toby. Especially at the end when he was yelling for Spencer at the police station. God, I felt so bad for him And the whole thing with Hannah interrupting the wedding? How awkward!! Kate is really going to make Hannah's life hell now, I'm predicting...
I do think it would be pretty awesome if they did keep with the twin story line. I really would like to see how it would play out, but if they say they're not going to do it, then I guess they're not going to. Then again, they could be just saying that to throw everyone off.
I know, me neither! Did you know there's going to be a Halloween special? I don't know the exact date, but it takes place when the girls are younger and Ali is still alive. It should be really interesting!

By the way, I hope no one who needs to catch up on PLL looks at our profiles...they're in for a hell of a lot of spoilers

Haha, don't worry about it.

Omg. I watched it like... 2 hours ago. Holy shist. :| Jenna and Garrett killed Alison? :| My God.
I still think that A/Ali's killer are all the same group of people. Maybe Ali kept a diary?
Yeah I heard about that but they're trying not to go with that I think.
Yeah good point, if you're into photography you take photos of flowers and trees and stuff. Not your one friend while she sleeps. Besides, she said Emily was her favourite.
That makes a lot of sense, and it'd explain why Ian *kind of* said he killed Ali if he lured her into it.
It was amazing! I want January to come for the second half of season two!

Sorry it's so short, I'm so, so tired.

I'm going to watch it again in a few minutes here. There are some things I don't catch the first time around, so I like to watch it a second time. Some things in it were painful to watch, but my eyes were like, glued to the screen. xD I can't wait till you watch it!!
I'm still wondering if A is different from the killer, though. Or, if the killer is in with a whole group of people who are stalking the girls around. I can't imagine if there was a whole group of people watching me and knowing my secrets. It's really freaky. But how would A know about the secrets the girls were keeping before Ali died? Was Ali spilling their secrets to someone else or something? Gosh, it's all so confusing. I really want to know who A is, but at the same time, I don't, because I love the show and want it to keep going on! It probably was a conspiracy. I think that Ali liked people hating her, honestly. But that really didn't bode well for her in the end, did it?
Yeaah, I think that's what happened in the books. She had a twin sister named Courtney, I think, who was secretly put into a mental institution because she was psychopathic or something like that. And when she was visiting they accidentally sent Ali back to the institution and courtney stayed and was pretending to be Alison. Something along those lines.
Oh god, I'm trying so hard not to reveal spoilers from last night's episode for you xD
Toby is really hot. And while I'm not attracted to girls, I think Maya is really cute
Right, no one knew about it. And honestly, if Ali did take the pictures, why were the only pictures Jason found of Aria? If Ali really liked photography, don't you think she'd take pictures of other things, and not just one of her friends? I think that Jason's pants might be on fire. Because like you said, Ali was a liar and hid a lot of things, and well, she's dead now, so = easy for Jason to make up lies about her.
Since Ian was part of the N.A.T. club, I'm thinking that Ian probably took Ali out to the Kissing Rock or whatever it's called to set her up for the murder. She was murdered, they said, on her walk home from the place where she was videotaped by Ian. So I'm thinking he took her there to set her up for it.
You're right, it's impossible for A to just be one person. A is always on top of things and always knows what's happening, even when the girls are separated. So it's gotta be more than one person. It's too hard for just one person to do all of this work.
You will NOT be disappointed at all with the finale. It was SO good. I can't wait till you watch it and we can talk about it.

No, I'm going to watch the full episode when I get home from college, I'm so excited!! It's going to be SO good!!
Yeah that's what I was thinking. I mean, I don't NEED sight restoring surgery, but if I got it, I doubt they could get me back to 20/20 again so it might just be that they give her the treatment and some REALLY strong glasses. I bet the people who hated Alison just formed a massive big club and created this huge conspiracy to kill her and scare the Hell out of the other girls.
I think in the books, Alison has a twin and that was how it all worked out eventually, but the producers or whatever of the TV series said they weren't going to follow that because it was too obvious to anyone who'd read the books. But then they might be just saying that. I repeat: it's all so confusing!
Toby is hot, even I won't deny that one. I always kind of liked him and was really upset when the police took him away at the end of the first series. (Or was that the end of part one of the first series? Too confusing!) I was sat with my laptop in the middle of the night like "NOOOO! Toby RUN! RUN NOW! NO! :cry:"
Despite what I just said about Toby, Maya is hot too. >.> Like very hot.
Ah, whoops. I knew what you meant. But it was late and I got confused. WHY did I think Mr. Hastings was Aria's dad? :|
It's not just Aria, no one knew anything about Ali and photography. And it's easy for Jason to make stuff up about Ali because everyone knows she lied, was amazing at hiding things, and no one can ask her since she's kinda... dead at the moment. So...
That's the thing, though. It makes too much sense for it to be Jenna. It must be another trick. If they make it obvious it's someone and then come out and say it is, then people will lose interest, you know? I'm pretty sure she has something to do with it, or knows about it, but that's as far as it goes.
Ian was in the N.A.T. club so if it was them, it was technically him too. Again: Big conspiracy. There's no way it's just one person doing all this, it's not possible. The old secrets from the first series? Sure, Ali knew about all them. But the past couple of months the notes have been about things that are going on there and then, there's no way one person could get so much dirt on 4 girls at the same time.