I guess I'm the first guy here.
1. Gerard Way, pre-Black Parade. I still have a crush on him, but he was so hot back then.
2. Zac Efron. Eyes+hair= <3
3. Mikey Way, looks a lot like his brother, but he didn't cut/dye his hair.
4. Tom Thacker from Gob. Before. Now he has a dirtstache and is ugly.
5. Adam Gontier. Pretty hot. It's the hair mostly.